ChiefsPlanet Mobile
Page 1 of 4
1 234 >
Nzoner's Game Room>Is Joe Thuney a hall of famer?
Titty Meat 03:38 PM Yesterday
4x super bowl champion
2x first team
2x second team
3x pro bowler

Never had a season with more than 10 penalties and regardless what the Humphries humpers say he helped save this season by moving to LT.
[Reply]
TLO 03:41 PM Yesterday
I don't think so, no.
[Reply]
mnchiefsguy 03:43 PM Yesterday
After his performance at left tackle this season, I do not think there is any fucking doubt.
[Reply]
Titty Meat 03:44 PM Yesterday
Originally Posted by TLO:
I don't think so, no.
But Will Shields for example is. I dont think Shields is a much better player than Thuney though
[Reply]
RedinTexas 03:44 PM Yesterday
Originally Posted by Titty Meat:
4x super bowl champion
If he wins upcoming SB, he will be tied with Charles Haley for the most SB championships of any non QB ever.
[Reply]
Gary Cooper 03:46 PM Yesterday
If the voters value playoff success more than Pro Bowls and All-Pro teams, sure.

Guard just seems like a difficult position to get in. Very exclusive list. In recent memory, they inducted Alan Faneca and Steve Hutchinson.

Will Shields had more personal accomplishments and wasn't a first ballot pick.

Brian Waters isn't in the HOF, yet his all-pro honors are similar to Thuney's.
[Reply]
Womble 03:48 PM Yesterday
The Hall of Fame is going to get bloated with Chiefs players on 5+ Super Bowls soon enough. I can't ****ing wait for it.
[Reply]
Pitt Gorilla 03:49 PM Yesterday
Yes.
[Reply]
Titty Meat 03:50 PM Yesterday
Originally Posted by Womble:
The Hall of Fame is going to get bloated with Chiefs players on 5+ Super Bowls soon enough. I can't ****ing wait for it.
Yeah Reid, Kelce, Mahomes are the obvious ones. 2 or so years ago Spags, Jones, and Thuney weren't. I'd say all of them should be in
[Reply]
smithandrew051 03:53 PM Yesterday
Originally Posted by Titty Meat:
Yeah Reid, Kelce, Mahomes are the obvious ones. 2 or so years ago Spags, Jones, and Thuney weren't. I'd say all of them should be in
Assuming he doesn’t shit the bed, Butker probably makes it too.

He’s going to have a long list of clutch kicks and titles on his resume.
[Reply]
ChiefsCountry 03:54 PM Yesterday

[Reply]
TLO 03:54 PM Yesterday
Does he deserve to be? Yes.
The reality is that guard is a difficult position to make it into the HOF. I don't know that it'll happen.
[Reply]
staylor26 03:54 PM Yesterday
Yes.
[Reply]
Titty Meat 03:56 PM Yesterday
Originally Posted by smithandrew051:
Assuming he doesn’t shit the bed, Butker probably makes it too.

He’s going to have a long list of clutch kicks and titles on his resume.
Yeah I totally forgot about Butker. I think he needs to keep producing for a few more years though before I'd put him in as a HOF kicker
[Reply]
smithandrew051 04:03 PM Yesterday
Originally Posted by Titty Meat:
Yeah I totally forgot about Butker. I think he needs to keep producing for a few more years though before I'd put him in as a HOF kicker
He’s not 30 yet, so being the Chiefs Dynasty kicker for another 5-6 years without a massive fall off probably gets him in eventually.

Basically becomes this generation’s Vinatieri. Another ring or two will help.
[Reply]
Page 1 of 4
1 234 >
Up