Originally Posted by tredadda:
Ummmm no. He’s easily a top 5 current WR, but top 5 all time? Nope.
You could argue that Tyreek Hill is the best WR of his generation. I'd definitely put him in the top 10-15 best WR of all time. He'd be a first ballot hall of famer if he didn't have as much off the field stuff. He still might even get there. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Lzen:
Wtf is this? This guy just pulling things out of his butt?
Where is he getting this info?
He's a Twitter tard that has no sources and just throws shit at the wall. He doesn't know anything at all and is just saying this is what a trade would look like. I think it'd cost a lot more than that considering the amount of money they'd be eating. [Reply]
Originally Posted by dlphg9:
You could argue that Tyreek Hill is the best WR of his generation. I'd definitely put him in the top 10-15 best WR of all time. He'd be a first ballot hall of famer if he didn't have as much off the field stuff. He still might even get there.
I don’t disagree with this. I just don’t see him as a top 5 all time WR. [Reply]
Originally Posted by tredadda:
I don’t disagree with this. I just don’t see him as a top 5 all time WR.
Who would you put over him in the top 5? Obviously Rice and Moss. But after that, I'd say there's a case for him to be in the top 5. I'd definitely pick him over Owens. Maybe even Fitzgerald. I just think past the first 2, it's all just personal preference, and I wouldn't disagree that there's a case for him to at least be talked about as one of the greatest. [Reply]
Originally Posted by tredadda:
Calvin Johnson, TO, Tim Brown, Fitzgerald, Harrison, Isaac Bruce, Cris Carter, Antonio Brown (before he went crazy). I would put all of them above Tyreek on my all time list and I only named a few.
Originally Posted by rydogg58:
Who would you put over him in the top 5? Obviously Rice and Moss. But after that, I'd say there's a case for him to be in the top 5. I'd definitely pick him over Owens. Maybe even Fitzgerald. I just think past the first 2, it's all just personal preference, and I wouldn't disagree that there's a case for him to at least be talked about as one of the greatest.
Originally Posted by tredadda:
Calvin Johnson, TO, Tim Brown, Fitzgerald, Harrison, Isaac Bruce, Cris Carter, Antonio Brown (before he went crazy). I would put all of them above Tyreek on my all time list and I only named a few.
I'm not going to cape for Hill as a top 5 all-timer, but he is a better and more impactful player than most of these. He's up there with Moss as one of the best ever at warping defenses. No coach would take Isaac Bruce over Hill. [Reply]