Because of all the interest in this thread, I've place all of the video content of Patrick Mahomes II's college career, and draft day goodness into a single post that can be found here. Enjoy! [Reply]
Originally Posted by PatMahomesIsGod:
Hit 136 times in 1.5 seasons. 2nd most.
I wonder if this is broken up by time? Maybe like hits from 0-2.5 seconds and hits taken after 2.5 seconds?
I know he’s a wizard and helps the offensive line out more than they help him, but he does also like to hang onto the ball until the very last second looking to make a play. I’m thinking that may be inflating the numbers a bit. [Reply]
Originally Posted by ThaVirus:
I wonder if this is broken up by time? Maybe like hits from 0-2.5 seconds and hits taken after 2.5 seconds?
I know he’s a wizard and helps the offensive line out more than they help him, but he does also like to hang onto the ball until the very last second looking to make a play. I’m thinking that may be inflating the numbers a bit.
Agreed. A big part of his talent is moving around and extending plays waiting for someone to break open. He may take more hits because of that, but they're often not the violent hits that we typically think about with the "quarterback hits" term. It's a dude pushing him outside the tackle box after he releases it. I'm not worried that he's taking disproportionate hits.
I saw a mini-interview with Joe Burrow the other day where he said something interesting. Yeah, I'll admit it: Joe Burrow said something interesting. He was asked about the number of sacks he takes, and he pftted. He said, "Sacks are really overrated. I don't care if I take a sack on third down because I'm holding the ball longer on third down to try to make a play. If no one's open and I take a sack, who cares as long as it doesn't push us out of field goal range?" [Reply]
Originally Posted by Rain Man:
Agreed. A big part of his talent is moving around and extending plays waiting for someone to break open. He may take more hits because of that, but they're often not the violent hits that we typically think about with the "quarterback hits" term. It's a dude pushing him outside the tackle box after he releases it. I'm not worried that he's taking disproportionate hits.
I saw a mini-interview with Joe Burrow the other day where he said something interesting. Yeah, I'll admit it: Joe Burrow said something interesting. He was asked about the number of sacks he takes, and he pftted. He said, "Sacks are really overrated. I don't care if I take a sack on third down because I'm holding the ball longer on third down to try to make a play. If no one's open and I take a sack, who cares as long as it doesn't push us out of field goal range?"
I think that’s a deafest attitude… Patrick scrambles to get guys open.. [Reply]
Originally Posted by pugsnotdrugs19:
After posting an 88 Total QBR yesterday and 82.6 last week in SF, Mahomes is ranked 7th overall this season amongst QBs at 67.1 (for comparison, he was 79.0 during 2022 - #1 in the NFL, last year he was at 63.9 - 8th in the NFL; although #1 in the playoffs at 86.9)
I've always loved this stat because it's never not passed the eye test IMO.
He's getting into his groove and with 10 games to go and an undefeated season in the balance, the MVP is still there for the taking.
Sometimes the numbers don’t make sense though. Trevor Lawrence somehow got a 79 grade on Sunday. He fumbled deep in his own territory to give 7 points to Green Bay in a game the Jaguars lost by one possession. When you fumble the game away, your QBR should not be any higher than 60/100.
Joe Burrow somehow graded close to 90 in a game where he scored 17 points. Team needed him to put 30+ on the board and he wasn’t close to that. Kirk Cousins had an awesome game and somehow they grade him 75/100. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Rain Man:
Agreed. A big part of his talent is moving around and extending plays waiting for someone to break open. He may take more hits because of that, but they're often not the violent hits that we typically think about with the "quarterback hits" term. It's a dude pushing him outside the tackle box after he releases it. I'm not worried that he's taking disproportionate hits.
I saw a mini-interview with Joe Burrow the other day where he said something interesting. Yeah, I'll admit it: Joe Burrow said something interesting. He was asked about the number of sacks he takes, and he pftted. He said, "Sacks are really overrated. I don't care if I take a sack on third down because I'm holding the ball longer on third down to try to make a play. If no one's open and I take a sack, who cares as long as it doesn't push us out of field goal range?"
Yep, either that’s a core tenet Burrow lives by and talks about frequently or we happened to watch the same interview. I thought that was interesting and generally hard to disagree with. A 3rd down sack taken when trying to extend the play is typically going to be pretty inconsequential.
On a similar note, I remember a Mahomes interview from a while back where he was asked about his completion percentage and he said “I’m not a big completion percentage guy”. I can’t remember his reasoning but, IMO, as long as it isn’t oddly low, I don’t really find myself caring too much about it either. As long as you’re above, like, 62ish% you should be fine.
Makes me wonder what core philosophies some other great QBs live by. [Reply]
Originally Posted by ThaVirus:
I wonder if this is broken up by time? Maybe like hits from 0-2.5 seconds and hits taken after 2.5 seconds?
I know he’s a wizard and helps the offensive line out more than they help him, but he does also like to hang onto the ball until the very last second looking to make a play. I’m thinking that may be inflating the numbers a bit.
Yeah, I've always felt like the PFF grades of our OTs are pretty low in part because of how Mahomes extends plays.
It's a good thing, don't get me wrong. But for instance I believe Taylor is outside of the top 50 starting OTs right now and that's just wrong. Even purely on his pass-blocking grades (which don't consider the penalties) he's outside of the top 35ish.
Naw - he's been a genuinely good pass protector all season. It's just the penalties (and occasionally run blocking) that's dinged him. But PFF says he's at best been average as a pass protector.
I just don't buy that. And this goes back several years; pretty much the entirety of Mahomes career. Our OTs are always about a tier below where my eye says they oughta be (and where several other stats such as pass rush win rate says they should be). [Reply]
Originally Posted by Rain Man:
He said, "Sacks are really overrated. I don't care if I take a sack on third down because I'm holding the ball longer on third down to try to make a play. If no one's open and I take a sack, who cares as long as it doesn't push us out of field goal range?"
That's not interesting, it's stupid brah.
He could fumble, etc. He will take hits that way. I just don't see where he's coming from. But then again, he isn't, nor ever will be as good as pat [Reply]
