Good catch. Not sure how I missed that.
[Reply]

The key here is this is the all elite all time guys BEST 73 games. The best football that's been played in modern NFL, versus Mahomes FIRST 73 games. Provided he hits a "prime" like the other guys did (like this year), there is a real argument that he WILL surpass all these guys.

There is certainly an argument against given our talent level on his rookie contract and our shit defense which required him to use his God tier talent to win games and with a better defense (hopefully) and fewer elite weapons, any gains from him getting acclimated to the league won't be as pronounced as the other guys.

But fuck it. I don't need graphics like this to tell me Mahomes is the best to ever play.

And besides, some of those are certainly explainable by things BESIDES the QB being good. Like total wins, he's behind Manning and Brady who got 6 easy wins a year by playing the DOG FUCK AFCS and AFCE. (Which is looking like the AFCW is headed this way, if cheap ass Spanos would trade Herbert, we might be there...)

And I care less about the INT numbers because Brees who won that category didn't push the ball much, EVER in his career. And if you're going to give me Mahomes with his picks or Brees without. I'm taking Mahomes. The big key is though that Rodgers "won" the comparison here, which I was always a Rodgers homer, but if you take the bad looks from Rodgers and the bad looks from Mahomes, I'm taking Mahomes every day of the fucking week. Sure, he put up big numbers beating on the bears and shit, but I'm rolling with my guy. So As always, I try to look at the aggregate story, not just some cherry picked stats.

Also, HOW THE HELL does Montana of all swinging dicks on this list lead in Rush TDs? Were there that many first and goal from the 1 plays?
[Reply]

You are correct with that chart. I misread it. For me when it comes down to it, not only does Mahomes put up amazing stats, but he is also must watch TV. I can’t think of any other player on that list being that. While all were great QBs, Mahomes is a human highlight reel and he does things no one on that list did or could have done. That’s what is so exciting about him.
[Reply]

Rodgers has always been proud of his TD to INT ratio, maybe a little too proud of it. He throws the ball away more than any QB, which means he is also killing the chance of a good play at the same time he’s killing the chance of a bad play.
[Reply]

[Reply]

I think Montana once held the record for QB rushing yards in a Super Bowl from SB XIX
[Reply]

Exhibit 23,993 as to why we should never run on 1st and 10.
[Reply]

Nah. A statistical quirk would be if you made a post on here that didn't mention Brady by name. Try it sometime. We all know you can't do it because patriot trash gonna be patriot trash, always.
[Reply]

you hear that meck?
[Reply]

1. You have to think the Super Bowl champ is coming from the AFC. I mean just look at the top right of this graph.

2. If we can beat the Bengals, we play some shit offenses the rest of the way.
[Reply]

[Reply]

yes, thank you for posting this again

this is bloody brilliant
[Reply]

while we're on the subject of joe campbell...words to live by


[Reply]

Their “best 73 games” vs Mahomes “first 73 games”.

Remarkable

You can tell the era that Joe Montana played in & how good he was.

Great chart.
[Reply]

[Reply]