Because of all the interest in this thread, I've place all of the video content of Patrick Mahomes II's college career, and draft day goodness into a single post that can be found here. Enjoy! [Reply]
Originally Posted by suzzer99:
Who are the top 3 - Lamar, Russel and Donald (but he had a down year right?)
1. Kittle
2. Donald
3. Wilson
4. Mahomes
Seems pretty fair to me. Mahomes was hobbled for about 80% of the season. Pretty high praise to have an injured version of him graded #4 in the league for the season. [Reply]
Originally Posted by DRM08:
1. Kittle
2. Donald
3. Wilson
4. Mahomes
Seems pretty fair to me. Mahomes was hobbled for about 80% of the season. Pretty high praise to have an injured version of him graded #4 in the league for the season.
I mean, it's just another example of why PFF can't be taken seriously.
It's a valiant effort they're trying to do, but they're grading without extremely important context: Player responsibility/assignment on each play.
They also negatively grade Mahomes more than they should because he makes throws that only he can make (and usually does make) but they "LOOK" dangerous for mere mortal QBs. [Reply]
Kittle wasn’t even the best player at his position. He just had a better grade due to his “blocking” which after the SB I’m not so sure isn’t severely overrated. He wasn’t blocking. He was holding. [Reply]