Other Sports ***The Official MMA Thread*** - Page 140

Excited about an upcoming fight? Want to make predictions, or just give people a heads-up that there are some fights on? We can do it here.

(Also a good place to complain, dicuss, and agrue about the outcomes)
[Reply]

Explain Japanese scoring rules plz.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by mdstu:
Not always, but I see your point. Do they have to turn their scores in after each round? I'm wondering if this is how we end up with these screwed up scores. I remember this being a problem in boxing.

No, I'm pretty sure they don't show scores until the end of the fight. I think it was the 3rd when I thought Shogun was done could have been a 10-8 round for Hendo so I think it was the right decision the way the scored it. I'd love to see it again since Hendo won't get a shot until after Machida and Evans at best. Maybe a shot at the Silva/Sonnen winner might be in the cards for him.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Shogun:
To the commission headbody only.

My bad, thanks. It's not that way in boxing right?
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Buck:
Explain Japanese scoring rules plz.

They make decisions based on the overall fight and outcome, in a nutshell.

Reference : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mixed_m..._.28defunct.29
[Reply]

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy:
My bad, thanks. It's not that way in boxing right?

It is, theres only 1 Athletic Commission for each state, not separately for boxing,mma, ect.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Buck:
Explain Japanese scoring rules plz.

It is my understanding that they judge the fight as a whole and not a 10 point must system?
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Shogun:
They make decisions based on the overall fight and outcome, in a nutshell.

Reference : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mixed_m..._.28defunct.29

Wow, that would be tough to score especially in a 5 round fight. I'd have to say the decision would still have been the same here.

Fresh Hendo pounding on Shogon > Gassed out Shogun laying on top of gassed out Hendo
[Reply]

The problem with that scoring system is that the latter rounds are probably weighted more, just because they are more fresh on the judges minds.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Buck:
The problem with that scoring system is that the latter rounds are probably weighted more, just because they are more fresh on the judges minds.

Yeah, like a street fight. The dude on top at the end wins regardless of what happened before.
[Reply]

They should look into using Fightmetrics, or at least providing them for the judges.

http://blog.fightmetric.com/2011/11/...icial-ufc.html
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Buck:
The problem with that scoring system is that the latter rounds are probably weighted more, just because they are more fresh on the judges minds.

Well, that is why there arent 5 rounds in japan :-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Shogun:
Well, that is why there arent 5 rounds in japan :-)

Do they still do a 10 and a 5 minute round like in Pride?
[Reply]

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy:
Do they still do a 10 and a 5 minute round like in Pride?

UFC bought Pride and pretty much dissolved the company. I remember Dream playing around with the 3 round system and even fighting in an octagon like cage with a nylon cage. I think that they are still using the 10/5 minute system now though.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy:
Do they still do a 10 and a 5 minute round like in Pride?

Hard to give a defined answer to that, yes and no. DREAM has been messing around with 3x5 rounds but mainly the 10 and 5. Shooto, Pancrase, ZST, Jewel and other do too. ZST is fucking weird though, they make their own rules, tag team mma champs imanari/tokoro ftw!
[Reply]