- Ranked 2nd among charted prospects in success rate vs. man (75%) and press coverage (75.7%) - Led all prospects in success rate vs. zone coverage (88.1%) - He can play inside and outsidehttps://t.co/HbifB61JlJpic.twitter.com/HYsV8rlAzF
Originally Posted by BossChief:
The Giants offense is ran by Kafka, that has not only exclusively coached under Andy, but also was drafted by Andy and played for Andy.
Yeah, I’d say Toney had a slight advantage (in understanding route concepts, play design, sight adjustments, reading NFL defenses, etc) over a guy coming out of a small school.
The plays called don’t need to be the same for the offense to be. Obviously Mahomes > Jones by a massive amount.
The Giants offense is designed by and RAN by Brian Daboll, you know, the career OC who's claim to fame was the Bills offense.
Kafka calls the plays.
It's like saying Reid's offense is RAN by EB. Get out of here with that.
It's Daboll's offense with some Kafka wrinkles and terminology. That's it. This is Daboll's offense. There's probably a fuck load more Bills shit in there than Chiefs.
You're out of your mind if you think Daboll just handed the keys over our old QB coach who's never so much as called plays, let alone design an entire scheme.
You guys are making way, way, waaaay too much out of the Kafka connection.
And Toney played in what, 2 games in that system as it is? And in those two games he barely saw any snaps.
So YES, Moore has had much more experience in THIS offense than Toney. That's just a fact. [Reply]
Originally Posted by DJ's left nut:
He was also hurt pretty much the entire time Kafka was running the offense.
So studying a playbook that might have some similar terminology to OUR playbook (but probably not much beyond that given that the Giants are a clear run 1st football team) is comparable to spending an entire camp and several games immersed in our system with our playbook and running our installs?
Oh, and Kafka 'runs the Giants offense' is a bridge too far in its own right. There's no way Dabol has just taken his hands off the wheel after being the OC for the Bills and having Josh Allen on his resume.
The point I’m failing to make is that the fair way to compare Toney (or Pickens) and Skyy isn’t current day but once they’ve had an equal chance to acclimate to the NFL game.
I think Toney is *by a considerable margin* a far more talented player, but if you were to judge NFL WRs based on their first 10 NFL games, you’d see a lot of problems. [Reply]
Originally Posted by BossChief:
The point I’m failing to make is that the fair way to compare Toney (or Pickens) and Skyy isn’t current day but once they’ve had an equal chance to acclimate to the NFL game.
I think Toney is *by a considerable margin* a far more talented player, but if you were to judge NFL WRs based on their first 10 NFL games, you’d see a lot of problems.
We understand your stance.
That he's not an elite caliber player, like the rookies we see every year come in and make a splash.
Hey man, we agree. That's we argued for a guy like Pickens who....you know...came in and made a splash. A guy who's showing early signs of being a legit playmaker.
"I like Toney more by a considerable margin" does not favor your stance here, my dude. [Reply]
I'm just thinking the game hasn't slowed down for him yet. Small school kid, first year....Toney big school and I know he had injury issues but dude is fast with nfl experience and 2 off-seasons. Hoping that's all and Moore will start having a positive impact [Reply]
Ya'll: "Hey guys, Moore's a small school prospect who's not ready to contribute and will need a season or two to develop into our 3rd or 4th receiving option as I don't view him to have the elite traits like a Toney and other rookie WR's"
Originally Posted by Detoxing:
Ya'll: "Hey guys, Moore's a small school prospect who's not ready to contribute and will need a season or two to develop into our 3rd or 4th receiving option as I don't view him to have the elite traits like a Toney and other rookie WR's"
US: "NO SHIT"
Pretty much.
Maybe don't take guys like that in the 2nd round would be my answer. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Detoxing:
The Giants offense is designed by and RAN by Brian Daboll, you know, the career OC who's claim to fame was the Bills offense.
Kafka calls the plays.
It's like saying Reid's offense is RAN by EB. Get out of here with that.
It's Daboll's offense with some Kafka wrinkles and terminology. That's it. This is Daboll's offense. There's probably a fuck load more Bills shit in there than Chiefs.
You're out of your mind if you think Daboll just handed the keys over our old QB coach who's never so much as called plays, let alone design an entire scheme.
You guys are making way, way, waaaay too much out of the Kafka connection.
And Toney played in what, 2 games in that system as it is? And in those two games he barely saw any snaps.
So YES, Moore has had much more experience in THIS offense than Toney. That's just a fact.
Yeah, the clone part was overstepping and devalues the rest of the information I put in there.
Let me put it a different way.
Toney had 4 seasons in the SEC and 1.5 years in the NFL before arriving in KC.
Skyy has had 3 years in the MAC, 1 offseason and 10 games adjusting to the NFL game. In a system known for taking time to pick up.
I think Skyy is going to have a game in the near future where he catches 5-6 balls for 75 and a TD and then is trusted more and more by Pat and by playoffs is a guy getting a lot more playing time.
I think them having him split time/focus on returns while also learning g Andy’s offense was a mistake that may have delayed his development…but not completely stopped it.
I originally anticipated it taking 8-10 weeks to get him involved in the offense and now think that realistic timeline should be 12-14.
And, yes…I still think his ceiling is Wes Welker (that also split time early in his career splitting time between WR and PR for Amos I before being traded to NE.
Maybe don't take guys like that in the 2nd round would be my answer.
They did the opposite with Mecole Hardman - big school, athletic freak, limited repertoire as a WR - and until this year, people were actually wishing the team would cut him.
Maybe it's a Chiefs thing and not a player thing. :-) [Reply]
Originally Posted by irafreak:
I'm just thinking the game hasn't slowed down for him yet. Small school kid, first year....Toney big school Hoping that's all and Moore will start having a positive impact
SEC is far superior in that regards. You play in the SEC you are facing future pros every game. [Reply]