Originally Posted by Quesadilla Joe:
"Most complete rookie back" but has to be taken out of the game in obvious passing situations because he's a dreadful pass protector.
Originally Posted by Quesadilla Joe:
"Most complete rookie back" but has to be taken out of the game in obvious passing situations because he's a dreadful pass protector.
Originally Posted by KranzDictum:
Hill is legit, I wouldn't go best in the NFL, he still drops too many easy passes to say he is the best. I don't know why Andy doesn't have alice chuck it deep to him every time he sees a single high safety and let reek use his speed to abuse the catch. He seems to understand how to get separation in traffic too so it could extend his career once his speed starts to go.
You guys hit on Hunt too. Not sure why he wasn't picked higher, must have been the small time college but he runs though trash very well. Another guy Andy needs to use more.
Read it again. I did not say that he was the best. I said that he was one of the best. And I stand by that. He is easily a top 10 receiver in the NFL. Top 5 may be pushing it, but he's close to that. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Quesadilla Joe:
"Most complete rookie back" but has to be taken out of the game in obvious passing situations because he's a dreadful pass protector.
A rookie RB that has issues pass protecting?! Oh no! Good things running backs can't get better at pass blocking......
The narrative that Hill has bad hands is also false. And what in the world kind of argument is "if he didn't have this" he wouldn't be as good?
If Hill is putting up these numbers before he learns to run routes then sign me up. You can improve on pass blocking. You can improve on running routes. Give me the talent and I will deal with them developing those skills. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Quesadilla Joe:
McCaffery isn't a gadget guy. He's a RB/slot receiver/returner. He has better hands and route running ability than Hill does.
I'm not saying Hill is a bad player. He's just not a number 1 WR. You completely neuter Hill by putting a safety over the top of him. Tyreek Hill is the last "#1 WR" I'd want to go to on 4th and 5 with the game on the line.
Making yourself look foolish...
Safety over the top is a made situation for Kelce down the seam. Safety retreating for deep coverage usually means LB on Kelce which opens the box for Hunt. See how that works? [Reply]
Hunt has had an incredible year... sure, the middle stretch was kind of bland. But, he looks to be closing it just as he opened it up, on a tear. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Quesadilla Joe:
McCaffery isn't a gadget guy. He's a RB/slot receiver/returner. He has better hands and route running ability than Hill does.
I'm not saying Hill is a bad player. He's just not a number 1 WR. You completely neuter Hill by putting a safety over the top of him. Tyreek Hill is the last "#1 WR" I'd want to go to on 4th and 5 with the game on the line.
At this point he's Steve Smith light. Which is pretty damn good. He has the potential to be that kind of player if he keeps improving.
You're gonna tell me Steve Smith isn't a #1 WR? [Reply]
Originally Posted by RealSNR:
At this point he's Steve Smith light. Which is pretty damn good. He has the potential to be that kind of player if he keeps improving.
You're gonna tell me Steve Smith isn't a #1 WR?
Any WR that can put up 1,000+ yards and 7+ TD’s with Alex at QB is clearly a #1. [Reply]
Originally Posted by RealSNR:
At this point he's Steve Smith light. Which is pretty damn good. He has the potential to be that kind of player if he keeps improving.
You're gonna tell me Steve Smith isn't a #1 WR?
Steve Smith was TO trapped in a small body. Tyreek Hill is a mix of Devin Hester and Reggie Bush. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Toad:
Making yourself look foolish...
Safety over the top is a made situation for Kelce down the seam. Safety retreating for deep coverage usually means LB on Kelce which opens the box for Hunt. See how that works?
Yeah I get it, Hill's speed makes him a great decoy. He's a special little gadget guy who's a threat to take it 80+ yards on every play. He just can't get open unless he outruns one-on-one coverage. [Reply]
